Showing posts with label Prophecy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Prophecy. Show all posts

Saturday, November 21, 2026

Hello Darkness My Old Friend

The trouble with prophets is that the people who think they are, and aren't, tend to shout from mainstage whilst the people who don't know they are, but are, tend to speak quietly in the corner.

The two main nudges to change our behaviour we got as a church at Trendlewood 2006-2022 came from one person who appeared grumpy and was not therefore listened to and one person who was a quiet voice at the back. It could be argued, although I have avoided arguing it because I don't come out of it well, that the biggest mistake we made came from the leader at the front (me) proceeding with something without a still small voice backing me up.

Why did I call this to mind? Two reasons. Firstly because catching up on last week's FT Weekend I read that commentators had missed the government's announcement that they would be allowing community hubs - places that combine shelter, company, assistance with life skills and job applications etc - to apply for government funding. Currently, as I understand it, a lot of them are supported by local councils or the charity sector. These hubs seem to help, and save money for the government in the long-term, but it is very difficult to quantify the cost of some not getting that help and to say that the hub was the only factor that helped. Governments have been in absolute hock to the need to demonstrate the financial advantages of an action so that things that are just obviously a good thing in their own right (community-building, friendship, support, life-skills) can be over-looked for funding.

Secondly a short video by James Ball pointed out that net migration figures owe far more than we think to what happened five years ago. People who immigrate and are accepted for whatever reason tend to either stay for five years or for ever. Now people staying for ever usually do so because they have a solid form of income and consequently pay taxes. People who come to study or escape usually want to go home.

Three to five years ago we saw a rush of escapees from Ukraine and we had to make good on our assurances to Hong Kong Brits. This saw a bulge in our figures which will be balanced in around 2028 (its peak). No government measure is changing this figure. It's just the way things are. We can expect the next, major protest against immigration in the mid-point between 2028 and 2033, roughly.

Politically leaders need to shout that they have stopped the boats and closed asylum hotels. They are doing this, but it is not what is making any difference to the immigration figures.

The 'prophets' who influence governments, for the most part, need to remain quiet voices in the corner. If they get too up-front or central, dirt will be found on them by 'helpful' journalists. It is not possible to only be advised by people who have never made a mistake. In fact learning from someone who did the same thing as you want to do but got it wrong and knows how is very useful. You build on their failure.

I have always liked listening for the still small voices in the corner and tend to be sparing about how much public acknowledgement (personal thanks is always offered) I give them until their advice has been accepted. As my friend Andy, a wise and now retired archdeacon once said, 'That's a very good idea; I wonder who should have it?' And those of us who try to get things done without being the centre of political attention - in my case church politics - learn to be content to find our ideas on other people's lips. Likewise, when someone more influential than me had a good idea (that is, one I agreed with and had probably had, but not broadcast) my job was to praise them, credit them and shout it to the rooftops.

The quiet corners of BlueSky Social and the FT comment pages are good places to find the words of the prophets. They are not written on subway walls - Paul Simon mistook slogans and soundbites for wisdom although his lyric was clever and The Sound of Silence an appropriate title.

I wonder which obscure publication or podcast I should investigate this week. Not one I've heard of yet, probably.